Gill Cunningham Murder Mysteries

[callmemadam]

These Gil Cunningham books by Pat McIntosh were recommended on Geranium Cat’s Bookshelf so when two turned up in our library I snatched them off the shelf. They are set in medieval Scotland and presented me with a few problems: I don’t know Glasgow, I don’t know much about Scottish history, I tend not to like historical novels.

I started with The Merchant’s Mark, which is the third book in the series. At first I was hopelessly confused by the location and the characters; I do think it would be better to read the books in order. Once the story got going I was away. Gil investigates a grisly murder which leads him on a (sometimes confusing, I have to say it again) chase involving the king, the knights of St John, officials of church and state and other villains. Meanwhile his sister Kate and Alys, his betrothed, stay home and carry out some investigations of their own. I like Kate a lot and particularly enjoyed her chapters.



I’m always annoyed when ‘medieval’ is used as a term of abuse, as if the whole period were just one Horrible History and we do everything better. Could the people who built the cathedrals and wrote the music and poetry which have come down to us be less intelligent than we are? So yay for novels about educated, thoughtful, medieval people. I found there was a little too much explanation (of coopering, for instance) but on the whole enjoyed the domestic details: Cynthia Harnett for grownups. Thinking of Cynthia Harnett made me want to read The Wool-Pack again.

Comments

[geraniumcat.livejournal.com]

I'm glad you enjoyed it - I think you are right about reading them in order. I had a lot of Scottish history more or less hammered into me at school, and I still found the first one I read quite confusing, but I thought Kate was splendid, and that they are fun.

[callmemadam.livejournal.com]

I found another one in the library today and grabbed that, too. Just read St Mungo's Robin and my favourite character in that was definitely Socrates. Thanks for the recommendation!